As households are being squeezed financially from the cost of living crisis in the UK to geopolitical instability in the Middle East, one uncomfortable question to address is how much does the public care about making greener decisions?
Since October 2022, the cost of living has been the most commonly reported issue facing the UK according to recent ONS data, cited by nearly 90% of survey respondents this year.
Six further issues followed as the most frequently reported including the NHS, the economy and crime before climate change and the environment made an appearance, with 53% of respondents citing this as a concern.
Meanwhile, consumer behaviour shows a reluctance to pay for sustainable buying decisions. Take e-commerce for example, with a YouGov survey finding that just 23% of Brits would pay more for greener deliveries.
Against that backdrop, Zag moderated a panel of researchers and sustainable logistics experts during London Climate Action Week. Hosted during a conference organised by European nonprofit Clean Cities and the Sustainable Urban Freight Association (SUFA), the discussion highlighted a critical path forward for decarbonising the UK’s delivery sectors.
That is, if both businesses and consumers are to embrace sustainable deliveries, the financial case must stack up.
Public attitudes to decarbonising transport
The panel, moderated by Zag’s Editor Sela Musa, began by examining how the public currently views the transition to cleaner transport.
Chris Annous, Strategic Communications Associate at More in Common, a UK think tank specialising in public opinion research, said the cost of living continues to overshadow almost every other issue.
“Engaged people in politics, and in Westminster particularly, can get bored of talking about the same old topics. But the public don’t,” Annous told the audience.
“And for the last two to three years, the number one issue facing the public when we ask them in our tracker every week has overwhelmingly been the cost of living.”
Annous said the current UK environment is one in which the cost of living is “an issue for basically everyone” with “everything flowing down from that”.
“The public get that we need to make this transition. They’re just really concerned that they can’t afford the transition,” he said.
“When you’re struggling to pay your bills, an extra cost here, an extra cost there, it really stacks up. From a public opinion perspective, they’re on board with the need to decarbonise and they actually may understand that it can reduce costs in the long run but, in the short to medium term, they’re concerned about paying their next bill.”
Debbie Chaplin, Senior Key Account Manager at Renault-owned Flexis which designs electric delivery vehicle solutions, brought business attitudes to the discussion on the electric transition.
“Particularly with vans and trucks, there’s a perception that an electric van is going to be more expensive or an electric truck is going to be more expensive,” Chaplin said.
While electric vehicles often carry a higher upfront purchase price than their internal combustion engine (ICE) equivalents, Chaplin argued that this overlooks their long-term value. Increasingly, electric fleets are equipped with connected technologies that reduce operating costs through tools such as fleet monitoring and route optimisation.
“It needs to be looked at more dynamically,” Chaplin said. “It can’t be looked at like ‘this is a white van and this is how much it costs to buy.'”
Louis Worthington from the Climate Change Committee echoed that view, arguing that falling battery prices and lower running costs are steadily strengthening the economic case for electrification.
“The long-term trend is really encouraging,” Worthington said. “The cost of battery electric vehicles has come down rapidly and we expect that trend to continue. Another key aspect is running costs and this presents a real opportunity for the transition to electric vehicles.”
The Climate Change Committee’s latest progress report on reducing emissions found that a typical household that has at-home charging saves money overall by switching to an electric car, thanks largely to lower running costs.
Across a range of household types, the report found savings for every group except high-income households. Estimated annual savings range from £350 to £950 based on energy prices before the Iran conflict, rising to between £450 and £1,580 after accounting for subsequent increases in energy prices.
Beyond electric vehicles – cargo bikes?
While the long-term economics for electric vehicles are improving, local policy can quickly alter the financial equation.
This year, London changed its Congestion Charge rules so electric vehicles are no longer exempt. Electric cars now receive a 25% discount, while electric vans and lorries qualify for a 50% discount. From March 2030, those discounts will fall further to 12.5% for cars and 25% for vans and lorries.
For some fleet operators, that policy shift has already influenced investment and procurement decisions.
“For at least one very large operator, a SUFA member, the 50% change has caused them to put 700 diesel vans back on the road,” Lee Pugh, Co-Chair of SUFA, told the audience.
“It’s as simple as that.”
To avoid those costs altogether, an alternative means of delivering is via cargo bike. Pugh, Founder of Colchester eCargo, argued that operators should look beyond simply replacing diesel with electric vehicles and pointed to cargo bikes as a solution that addresses the critical challenge of limited road space.
“An electric van or a diesel van – so many of these vans running around our towns and cities are bringing in stuff that’s available locally,” he said.
Whatever the green mode of vehicle, the panel made clear that public support for decarbonising transport and logistics already exists. The challenge isn’t convincing businesses and consumers that greener deliveries matter, it’s making sure the sustainable choice is also the affordable one.
