Shared micromobility is entering its most financially scrutinised phase and the industry’s long-running debate over what operators should own, outsource and specialise in is becoming impossible to ignore.
On June 1st, Zag Daily and Urban Sharing will tackle this question head on with an exclusive ‘Build vs Buy’ showdown in Berlin, uniting operators, investors and city stakeholders to test which business models are equipped to survive the next phase of the market.
Three operators will defend their strategies under direct challenge before judges and the audience weigh in with their verdict on which model is best positioned to scale and last.
Ahead of his keynote, Zag sits down with Urban Sharing’s Chief Revenue Officer Tom Nutley who reveals why he thinks the micromobility industry is entering its “fourth bubble” and how it makes the Build vs Buy question more critical than ever.
Zag Daily: Why does the shared micromobility industry need to have this debate right now?
Tom: “The industry is going through what I would call a fourth bubble. The first wave was docked public bike share which was followed by dockless bikes, private scooters and rapid expansion and now we’re seeing a fourth phase where public and private models are converging under real pressure to become financially sustainable. The question is who adapts to that the quickest. For me, this event is about getting people in a room who are willing to admit what is not working, even if it’s their own business model.”
Zag Daily: What will your keynote cover?
Tom: “I want to walk through where this industry started and where it has got to today. There have been roughly six or seven iterations of shared micromobility which saw the industry go from docked retail bikes in the 1960s operate through coin-operated systems to the era of Clear Channel and advertising-integrated schemes, and now into the modern landscape. I want to map that journey and use it to set the scene for the panel, showing how the industry has separated into public and private models and how the movers and shakers have played their hands very differently.”
Zag Daily: What’s the difference between the all-in-one and best-in-class model?
Tom: “A best-in-class solution means a consortium uniting the leading players in each vertical. You select the optimal tool for each part of the system whether that’s fleet management software, operations partners, payment processing, the rider app or the hardware. A 360, or all-in-one, solution is a single vendor offering everything in one bundle which is appealing for its simplicity but often comes at the cost of flexibility and innovation. That said, no model is ever truly fully in-house and it never should be. Most electric vehicles use Bosch motors. Most bikes use Shimano brakes. For me it comes down to who owns the main software platform, who owns the bike frame design and delivery, who owns the 80%.”
Zag Daily: Urban Sharing started as a 360 platform. What did that experience teach you?
Tom: “We learned the hard way and we’ve got the scars to prove it. We launched as a full 360 platform. We did ops, hardware and software and some of that hardware is still in use in Norway today. We decided in 2018 that software was where we wanted to focus. Hardware was hard, there were already good players in that space and 3PLs were emerging. What we recognised was that building a fleet platform staffed by people who had actually run and operated systems, rather than a software company coming in from the outside saying this looks like a nice market to attack, was a USP we could genuinely offer.”
Zag Daily: What’s the core argument against the all-in-one model?
Tom: “If you are running ops and developing hardware and software simultaneously, you are splitting your focus three ways. You risk stagnating or falling behind people who concentrate entirely on one area. The jack of all trades is master of none. There are providers doing the 360 model well but in a market where focused verticals are becoming increasingly competitive, the risk of being overtaken grows. We have seen it before in other industries. Think Nokia and Blockbuster. If you do not define your strategy and innovate accordingly, you cannot move.”
Zag Daily: What’s the case for the 360 model?
Tom: “Control and ownership are real advantages. When you outsource, you become subject to other people’s supply chains, other people’s roadmaps and other people’s resourcing. The 360 model maintains ownership across the entire cycle. You also get efficiency end-to-end.
“The most tangible example is the user experience. When your software is talking to the IoT on the bike, which is talking to an NFC reader, lights and the rider app, and something fails, who do you call? You might contact the software partner because that is where the error is appearing but the problem could be in the hardware. When you own that whole chain, you get to a resolution much faster.”
Zag Daily: What is the central question you want this event to answer?
Tom: “The core one is this: we are businesses first and foremost and businesses only survive if they are making more money than they are losing. What is the optimal approach to make shared micromobility actually work financially? Look at recent acquisitions like nextbike or Inurba. Both of them run very different operational models and both were acquired partly because they’re EBITDA is positive. One does not carry hardware on its books, the other does. So if the margin exists in both cases, why are so many players still trying to cram all of that under one roof?”
Zag Daily: One of the biggest headlines has just hit the micromobility industry: Lime’s IPO. How is this relevant to the debate?
Tom: “It’s very relevant. Lime is the largest player in the private scooter and micromobility space globally. They have gone through enormous funding rounds, they have more in-house capability than almost anyone and yet, according to the S-1, losses significantly outpace revenue with no clear path to closing that gap due to poor capital decisions made in the ‘growth at all costs’ phase. That is not a knock on the people involved. It is an honest look at what the numbers are telling us. The private operator model, as currently constituted, is not working. That is a question this panel needs to confront directly, not dodge.”
Zag Daily: Why is Berlin the right place for this conversation?
Tom: “Berlin is the proving ground for private micromobility. The city pulled public funding and yet it has some of the highest vehicle numbers and the most operators of anywhere in Europe. That context matters for this debate. It also leads naturally into the broader picture for micromobility across Europe which is very much part of what we want to set up going into Micromobility Europe the following day.”
