Forest’s Caroline Seton on London’s shared e-bike reset: “The time has absolutely come”

In #44 of Zag’s Women Making Moves series, Forest Co-Founder Caroline Seton sets out her non-negotiables for London’s upcoming city-wide framework for dockless e-bikes.

Share this article

London is on the brink of one of its biggest shake-ups for how dockless e-bikes are managed across the city.

Earlier this year, the English Devolution Bill gave Transport for London (TfL) powers to establish a single, London-wide licensing framework for dockless e-bike operators. The move aims to replace the borough-by-borough “patchwork problem” that has shaped the market for years with different rules on fleet caps, operator numbers, parking and pricing across the capital. 

But the new system is not yet set. The London Assembly Transport Committee is meeting this week to examine what powers should be handed to TfL as part of the future regulatory framework and how they’d work in practice.

For operators, the stakes are high. A single framework is hoped to remove some of the friction of operating across London but the new powers will also determine how much room the sector has to grow.

Few people are better placed to assess what that means than Caroline Seton, Co-Founder of London homegrown e-bike operator Forest. We sit down with her to examine the reality of operating a dockless bike business across the UK capital today and what she wants to see from the city’s new rules. 

Zag Daily: Can you tell us about yourself and how you got into co-founding Forest?

Caroline: “Gosh, that’s a great question. I founded Forest with Agustin Guilisasti and Mike Stewart in 2019 – we’re coming up to our seven year anniversary. Forest was born from an idea of Agustin’s. His background is transport, he launched ride-hailing in Latin America for Cabify and had also ran a micromobility business for them. He was on sabbatical in London studying for a Master’s in data science and saw the huge opportunity London presented for shared mobility. At the time, shared micromobility in the city was underdeveloped. Santander was probably doing around 30,000 trips per day and the shared e-bike operators were doing roughly 10,000 to 20,000. That has grown significantly over the last six years as the way Londoners move has changed.

“I came to Forest to lead on policy and legal. As a founding team, we had an amazingly complementary mix of skills. Mike leads on marketing and you can really see his magic in how the Forest brand is perceived and nurtured. Agustin brought the mobility experience. I’m a former lawyer and had been working in public affairs and public relations, advising FTSE 100 clients on their strategies. So I brought that lens to help secure our licence to operate.”

Zag Daily: Can you say more on what being a former lawyer let you bring to Forest?

Caroline: “As a startup, you have to be careful with costs and retaining London law firms is hugely expensive, so having an ex-lawyer on board with experience across multiple areas is invaluable. There’s a perception that lawyers can do everything when in fact they specialise: property, M&A and so on. But I was lucky. I’d been through a graduate programme and while I didn’t have full experience in every area of law, I’d sat in many departments and could handle the basic legal issues or at least know what questions to ask or when to get specialist advice without needing to pay the full whack on a project fee. That kept us very budget-focused.

“I was able to negotiate the contract on our first warehouse, draft the employment contracts and work with a private practice on our early funding rounds. Now, of course, we have a General Counsel and a well-resourced legal function.”

Zag Daily: Forest’s lean approach paid off with you becoming one of the first micromobility operators to hit profitability. Can you give us the Forest pitch now? What are the numbers?

Caroline: “We recently reached the milestone of having the largest service area of any operator in London. Other major milestones have been reaching three million rides per month, two million users and a fleet of 25,000 bikes. We’re not the largest operator by number of bikes but being number one by service area is a huge achievement because it means we’re maximising the availability of bikes on the street and doing it as efficiently as possible.

“We now hold 20 borough licences, plus three further operating agreements, all earned through procurement processes and six years of working closely with councils to understand what they need and deliver a service that meets it. That’s complicated because there’s no one-size-fits-all approach; each borough wants something different. Those licences are a testament to the team and to our ability to design a service for each borough as a company focused solely on London. We’re a London company for Londoners. Our management team lives here and we live and breathe the operations on the ground so we can tailor our service to the city.”

Zag Daily: Those 20 separate London contracts will all change with the upcoming city-wide dockless e-bike framework introduced by the English Devolution Bill. What are your thoughts on the legislation? 

Caroline: “We’re pro-legislation and have been advocating for this for three years. In our view, the time has absolutely come for a collective vision for cycling in London. We fully support the Mayor’s ambitious target of 80% of trips being made by walking, cycling and public transport by 2041 and we’re already playing our part in getting there. The Mayor has done an incredible job of expanding the cycle network, reducing reliance on cars and introducing the ULEZ. But there are still friction points between stakeholders with competing demands and priorities and we need to think about how those priorities can sit alongside one another in a way that best supports a vision for London as a cycling city.

“Take parking, for example. In some cases, boroughs are reluctant to give over parking space to bikes while also wanting to increase cycling. To grow cycling responsibly, cities need a commensurate increase in infrastructure to accommodate the demand. In one London borough, residents were complaining about too many bikes on match days. The council came up with a solution: temporarily suspending car parking bays and converting them to bike parking on match days. But residents didn’t agree. So what’s the answer? Education is one part of it. We need to keep explaining why the active travel goal exists and it comes back to air quality. If you look at parking in a silo, it can seem that nothing is gained from giving car parking spaces over to bikes. But what’s gained is better air quality: approximately 13 tons of CO2 avoided per day, equivalent to the emissions from driving an average petrol car around 50,000 miles. That’s why every stakeholder needs to be brought into the collective vision.”

Zag Daily: How has Forest personally felt the “patchwork problem” in London?

Caroline: “Currently, boroughs can require us to charge a set price as part of tender agreements. Two boroughs have already done so and a third is on the way. Often, boroughs want to peg the price of a dockless bike ride to a bus fare. That doesn’t make sense because bus fares are subsidised as part of the public transport system, whereas shared bikes are a private service. Many boroughs are thinking about what’s best for their residents but not more widely about the overall transport mix and how to keep cycling growing. If they intervene in private business models by setting a dockless bike fare at bus-fare levels, which is a very different proposition, they risk deterring investment. That could ultimately undermine the sector and its ability to deliver a quality service for London.

“We’re not necessarily at that point yet. But telling an operator what it must charge, without looking at its business model or the costs it incurs, is a very different proposition and could become a serious threat to bike share. This is still a relatively young industry. It’s vital that we keep innovating and investing in safety and technology upgrades, improving the bike, the app and the operational workflows so they run better in the public realm. But if you squeeze both ends of the P&L, that becomes really difficult.”

Zag Daily: The London Assembly Transport Committee is meeting this week to discuss the new regulatory framework for dockless e-bikes. What do you want to see from a pan-London system?

Caroline: “First, reasonable fleet caps. Legislation mustn’t hold back the growth of shared bikes by pulling fleet caps back. What we consistently find is that when bike density in an area increases, trips per bike per day increase too. The more bikes there are, the more integrated they become in people’s commuting habits and the more reliable the service is. A significant step back in fleet caps, whether per operator or overall, would limit the scheme’s growth and set us back.

“The second is pricing. Operators need to be able to charge what makes commercial sense. That doesn’t mean we’re not focused on affordability. Forest was founded on making the service both financially sustainable and affordable. But we need the freedom to design bundles, flexible subscriptions and products that work for different people and use cases. A blanket fixed price won’t work in the long term.”

Zag Daily: What fleet or operator cap do you call for in London?

Caroline: “I’d expect there to be two to three shared dockless bike operators in London, similar to many other cities. The operator cap will depend on the fleet cap and operators need a London-wide fleet large enough to justify investment. We’re fortunate to have three warehouses and a large team and that scale brings operational efficiencies and better performance. If there’s a problem with a bike, there’s likely to be a Forest team member nearby simply because of the scale we operate at. Whatever the number of operators, each needs to be able to operate at a scale that delivers well for the city.

“More generally, we think there are around 350,000 shared bike trips per day in London right now. And we think it could reach 1.5 million. London has excellent topography for shared cycling and great connectivity, particularly in boroughs where established transport options like the rail or tube aren’t so available. Dockless bikes are unlocking areas with poor commuting links and helping people move into houses on the outskirts where they need a lower deposit because they can still commute into the city by cycling. So we see the numbers easily being able to increase in London.”

Zag Daily: As this legislation is drafted, are there any fatal mistakes you want to warn London authorities from making?

Caroline: “The pan-London licence needs to support the Mayor’s globally ambitious target for cycling. The evidence of the last five years shows that shared e-bikes are fundamental to achieving the Mayor’s legacy on active travel. We need to ensure that any fleet caps are set at a level which doesn’t undermine that ambition. Dockless hire is growing faster than cycling overall. Caps should therefore grow with parking capacity and be earned through performance.”

Zag Daily: Does Forest have any plans to expand outside of London?

Caroline: “We’re fully focused on London.”

Most read

ADVERTISING