When it comes to transport, the morning commute is rarely a rational decision.
“You’re already running late, the bus is four minutes behind, your e-bike battery was dead last time so you grab the car keys,” Michael Semmer, Co-Founder of Urban Places Lab, said as he opened his keynote on day one of the Smart City Expo World Congress in Barcelona.
That split-second choice, Semmer argued, exposes the psychology behind why decades of investment in cycling lanes, shared mobility schemes and electric fleets still struggle to pull people out of cars.
“The real challenge isn’t building more options. It’s helping people choose differently.”
Semmer, whose team launched a public–private mobility hub in Basel, Switzerland, with support from EIT Urban Mobility, resorted to behavioural science to explain why commuters cling to the car despite mounting alternatives. Status quo bias, loss aversion (feeling a loss more than feeling a gain), perceived control and social norms all reinforce car dependency, while tiny “friction costs” like a flat bike tire or an app update are enough to push people back into the driver’s seat.
Nudging the norm
A panel session followed Semmer’s keynote, exploring how cities can apply behavioural insights to shift everyday travel choices.
Moderated by EIT Urban Mobility’s Thought Leadership Manager Yoann Le Petit, the discussion brought together Lukas Neckermann, Managing Director of Neckermann Strategic Advisors and Co-Founder of Urban Places Lab, with Ola Rynge, Chief Technology Officer of behavioural tech firm Nudgd.
For Rynge, the key to modal shift lies in pairing physical infrastructure with soft interventions or ‘nudges’.
“You can build the bike lanes and mobility hubs but that doesn’t mean people will use them,” he said. “Nudging makes it easier to choose what’s good for you and society.”
The concept, borrowed from behavioural economics, involves small prompts or design tweaks that steer people toward sustainable choices without restricting freedom. For instance by sending reminders, framing options positively or making alternatives visibly popular.
But nudging alone isn’t enough, Rynge cautioned, adding that personalised, context-aware nudges work far better than generic campaigns. “When messages are adapted to specific workplaces, schools or neighbourhoods, behaviour change can jump from 10% to 40%.”
Neckermann agreed that infrastructure can act as both “nudge and hammer.” Removing parking spaces, for example, creates new friction for drivers while freeing up room for bike or car-sharing stations. “The key is to build for where you want to go, not where you are,” he said.
The tipping point
Both panellists stressed that behaviour change is contagious. Research shows that once roughly a quarter of a community adopts new travel habits, the rest soon follow.
“When 25% of your neighbours start cycling, suddenly it feels normal,” Neckermann said. “Social tipping points are incredibly powerful.”
For Semmer, Basel’s mobility hub demonstrates how this can be achieved through co-creation. Employees and local residents were invited to help design the site which combines shared bikes, e-scooters and car-sharing in a single location. The initiative has already boosted vehicle utilisation rates and reduced pressure on city streets.
But lasting transformation, he said, requires constant iteration. “Mobility change is never finished,” he reminded the audience. “You have to measure, measure, measure and then adapt.”
