Image Credit: Seb Doe, Unsplash
London drivers are willing to cut car use when the conversation focuses on fairness, the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) has found.
A new study reveals that when drivers are included in the debate, and when a clear link is made between their driving and congestion, a reduction in car use is supported for different groups of drivers.
Drivers who took part in the study believe that disabled people and carers should be able to maintain their current driving levels. Meanwhile, it’s thought fair for wealthier drivers and those living next to public transport to reduce their car use to support London in overcoming its congestion and climate challenges.
The research comes amidst a backdrop of ‘anti-motorist’ rhetoric in the UK, where policies aimed at reducing car use are often seen as a “war on motorists”.
To shift away from this narrative, Dr. Philipp Rode, lead author and Executive Director of LSE Clean Cities, told Zag Daily that people should not be classified according to the mode of transport they use – such as ‘motorists’ or ‘cyclists’ – a practice he argues is simply “not helpful”.
Rather, the conversation should shift to how long and how often different social groups should be supported with their driving needs.
“At certain points, many people in London will have to use a car even if they normally don’t – be it a taxi, shared vehicle, van or otherwise,” Dr. Rode said.
The researchers came to their findings by conducting a representative survey for London, a simulation citizens’ jury with nine participants, a pilot behavioural experiment and in-depth interviews with 19 London car drivers.
Measures put forward to reduce car use over recent years, such as those on Ultra Low Emission Zones and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods, have been met with opposition, the study states. Rather than relying on traditional surveys that collect “status-quo sentiments”, Dr. Rode believes a “far more productive” method of consultation is by engaging a diverse group of the public that’s more representative of the overall population. The consultations should be in depth, with information shared prior to the debate that “explicitly” highlights the trade-offs of driving in inner cities.
Three elements for a constructive discussion are presented by the study: using deliberative formats such as citizens’ juries or assemblies; centering the debate around fairness; and demonstrating the clear link between an individual’s driving choices and congestion levels. In turn, a fairness-based approach is hoped to support policymaking that reduces polarisation in the discussion of car use.
