Image credit: Zoshua Colah, Unsplash
Cities are run by a medley of transportation modes: buses, bikes, light rail, subways, taxis, tuk-tuks, all operating in a complicated dance designed to move people efficiently.
In numerous cities around the world, autonomous vehicles (AVs) are already embedded in the flow of a city’s transportation network. However in India, the case for introducing AVs into the shuffle is still up for discussion.
The current state of AVs in India
Today, AVs are in early stages of development and testing in India. In 2016 the former CEO of Uber, Travis Kalanick, said that India would be the last country to get autonomous vehicles based on the informal nature of how people traverse the city, or what researchers from the Indian Institute of Technology Ropar call “traffic indiscipline”.
Many AV pilots in the US and China rely on both 3D maps of set geographic areas to help vehicles navigate roadways, and set “rules” for how to navigate city streets. The technology relies on dedicated, formalised street systems and travel behaviours, making it difficult to replicate on India’s less structured street layouts.
Today there are only a handful of start-ups testing on Indian roads. Companies such as Bhopal-based Swaayatt Robots, Kochi-based RoshAi, and Bengaluru-based Minus Zero are all taking different approaches to bring the technology to India’s streets without the need for 3D maps or strict rules.
AV’s potential for leisure travel in India
Despite the barriers to introducing AVs in India, researchers are still optimistic about the potential for them to transform how people will move across the nation. New research from the Indian Institute of Technology Ropar, done by Nikhil (Research Scholar, Department of Civil Engineering) and Dr. Rahul T.M. (Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering) looks at the perceived safety gains and benefits that AVs can have on long-distance non-essential trips in India. The researchers focused on travel that is associated with leisure, socialising, shopping, and recreation, and how AVs would increase access for these types of activities.
Positive perceptions of AVs are suggested to “motivate people to increase the frequency and the distance travelled for such long-distance discretionary travel.” The researchers associate the willingness to travel more often and further to the perceived safety and comfort benefits provided by AVs.
“While buses and trains form the backbone of discretionary travel in India, they often suffer from infrequent services, lack of connectivity, and limited comfort, particularly due to challenges in first and last-mile connectivity that make accessing transit hubs or final destinations inconvenient,” said Nikhil.
The study points out that AVs add reliability to India’s already existing transportation systems, which can be helpful to tackle inaccessibility caused by gaps in existing transport networks. The research suggests that AVs can alleviate access challenges for key groups such as women and ageing communities, however, these benefits will be limited at first to higher income groups. According to researchers, “affordability will be key to making [AVs] inclusive across income groups.”
The researchers hint at multiple tensions that will emerge when India does adopt AVs. These tensions include: the competing relationship with public transportation systems that already exist; who will have the financial means to access these more comfortable and higher-end transportation options; and what long-term implications for India’s existing transport inequality could emerge.
How AVs could transform India’s rural landscape
One area where this tension could be addressed is in rural India, which is home to 909 million people – the vast majority of India’s population.
Rural India has heightened transport challenges compared to its urban centres, with limited access to affordable, reliable, safe, and sustainable forms of transportation. In rural areas, AVs have an opportunity to revolutionise mobility for communities through affordable first and last-mile transportation connections. However, the vast majority of global AV trials and research focus predominantly on urban contexts, leaving behind an opportunity to connect hundreds of millions of people.
“In urban and especially planned city contexts, residents are more exposed to emerging technologies, and infrastructure is comparatively more supportive. In rural regions, challenges such as limited infrastructure, lower digital literacy, and strong dependence on traditional modes mean perceptions and adoption of AVs may differ significantly,” said Nikhil.
Despite the potential of AVs to connect rural communities, it’s unlikely rural pilots will be prioritised during the testing and trial phases of AVs. According to the researchers, “infrastructure gaps in roads, lane markings, and [lack of] signage further hinder readiness,” in rural communities. While Nikhil and Dr. Rahul believe that rural areas also stand to benefit from AVs, it is only “if these barriers can be addressed.”
While AVs are often touted as solutions to many transportation problems, from congestion and road fatalities to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, they are predominantly found in urban centres that could invest in alternative means to achieve each of these goals, such as mass transit and improved road infrastructure.
Without a dedicated effort to connect rural communities with AVs, Indian transport systems run the risk of further alienating rural communities from affordable, sustainable, and comfortable transportation options.
AVs could have an outsized impact in rural areas, but that requires governments to invest in improving infrastructure, closing a digital divide, and ensuring that AVs can be offered at affordable rates to residents across income levels.
